Yuanta

Franko Knavs

1-2년

How do Yuanta's overnight financing charges, or swap fees, stack up against those of other brokers?

WikiFX 대답

As someone who has traded across numerous platforms, I appreciate the importance of overnight financing charges—often called swap fees—in managing long-term trading costs. From the available information, Yuanta applies a margin interest rate of Prime Rate plus 5% for trading on margin. While this isn’t labeled explicitly as a swap fee in the typical forex sense, for positions held overnight, this margin interest rate effectively functions as the carrying cost—especially relevant when considering leveraged positions in stocks and derivatives. Compared to many international brokers, this rate is on the higher side. Some global brokers offer more competitive swap or financing rates, especially on major forex pairs or large-cap equity CFDs, where spreads and financing costs are strong selling points. The absence of a detailed, published swap/rollover schedule for each asset at Yuanta makes it difficult for me to anticipate precise costs in advance, which is something I find less transparent than I would like for effective risk management. My experience with other Hong Kong-based and global brokers has shown that financing rates, and the associated lack of detailed disclosures, can impact long-term profitability if not watched carefully. If overnight financing is a key part of your strategy, I would recommend reaching out to Yuanta's customer service for specifics before committing significant capital, as apparently high administration or nominee fees may further affect your net returns. As always, understanding your total cost of trading is crucial for prudent financial decision-making.

Broker Issues

Yuanta

Fees and Spreads

08-29

미국

Aman A

1-2년

Can you outline the particular advantages Yuanta offers in terms of its available trading instruments and fee system?

WikiFX 대답

Drawing on my own experience as a trader evaluating brokers, Yuanta stands out primarily for its broad access to global markets and overall regulatory stature. For me, the key advantage lies in the ability to access a diverse menu of instruments: Yuanta offers a comprehensive set of products ranging from Hong Kong, mainland China, Taiwan, and US stocks to derivatives like warrants, callable bull/bear contracts, as well as futures and options. This breadth can be valuable for anyone seeking to construct a multi-asset portfolio or access market opportunities beyond just spot forex. In terms of the fee structure, while Yuanta's administrative and nominee service charges may occasionally be on the higher side, the core trading costs—such as commission rates and margin interest rates—are generally aligned with major Hong Kong brokers. The standard equity commission, for instance, is set at 0.25% of the transaction amount with a minimum of HK$100, which, in my view, is typical for the region. There aren’t deposit or withdrawal fees from Yuanta itself, though I am always cautious to check for potential third-party bank charges, especially for international transfers. The biggest caveat, in my opinion, is the absence of a demo account—which makes it harder to test their proprietary platforms risk-free. All things considered, I appreciate Yuanta's product depth and transparent, regionally competitive fee structure, but I remain mindful of platform limitations and would only proceed after thorough due diligence and a careful review of actual trading and withdrawal processes.

Broker Issues

Yuanta

Regulation

07-09

미국

Ashraf Shahhat

1-2년

Could you break down the total trading costs for trading indices such as the US100 on Yuanta?

WikiFX 대답

Based on my experience as a trader and after reviewing Yuanta’s structure, the total cost of trading indices such as the US100 with Yuanta involves several components that need close attention. Yuanta’s commission for stock transactions is 0.25% of the transaction amount, with a minimum charge of HK$100 per trade. However, since indices are generally accessed via futures or derivatives, the exact fee for US100 index trading could be slightly different—often realized through derivatives commission or contract-specific fees. Additional transaction costs include standard Hong Kong market levies: stamp duty at 0.10%, transaction levy at 0.0027%, and a trading fee at 0.00565%, though these may apply directly to equities rather than index contracts. For futures and options products, margin interest (Prime + 5%) and contract specifications will play a role in cost, so clarity on the contract type is essential. One positive for me is Yuanta does not impose direct fees on deposits or withdrawals, but third-party or banking costs could arise, especially for international remittance or certain transfer types. Lastly, the absence of a demo account makes it difficult to fully preview these costs in a risk-free environment before trading live. Given the steps involved, it’s prudent I always calculate expected charges based on my planned trade size and frequency, and carefully review the specific terms for the chosen index contract on Yuanta’s platform. This conservative approach has helped me manage risk and avoid unwanted surprises in my trading costs.

Broker Issues

Yuanta

Fees and Spreads

06-21

미국

Ashraf Shahhat

1-2년

Does Yuanta provide traders with the option to open an Islamic (swap-free) account?

WikiFX 대답

As an experienced trader, I have learned to carefully review brokers’ account offerings, particularly when it comes to specialized options like Islamic (swap-free) accounts. After examining Yuanta’s available information, I did not find any indication that Yuanta provides an Islamic or swap-free account option for traders adhering to Sharia principles. Their documentation focuses on standard stock, futures, and derivative trading, primarily for the Hong Kong and major international markets, and there’s no mention of any Islamic account variant. In my experience, clear communication about account types is critical for transparency and trustworthiness, especially given regulatory and ethical concerns faced by traders requiring swap-free services. When a broker does not explicitly advertise or document such an option, I personally interpret that as an absence of support for Islamic account needs. Furthermore, the lack of a demo account and some user feedback pointing to withdrawal difficulties makes thorough due diligence even more important for anyone with specific account structure requirements. For me, unless Yuanta officially confirms the availability of an Islamic account, I cannot rely on them to meet those particular trading needs. I always recommend reaching out directly to their support for clarification before considering them if this is a key factor.

Broker Issues

Yuanta

Instruments

Leverage

Platform

Account

06-13

미국